Council to Vote on Homeless Encampment Ban

Los Angeles City Council to continue controversial item November 24

By Sam Catanzaro

Los Angeles lawmakers are set to vote on a bill that would allow the removal of homeless encampments anywhere in the city if officials first offer shelter to unhoused individuals. 

The ordinance would also allow City of Los Angeles officials to remove homeless encampments at freeway underpasses, near homeless shelters and in areas that restrict ADA access if unhoused individuals were first offered shelter.

The “legislation…will replace out-of-date laws, clarify how we can keep our streets and sidewalks clean, increase ADA access and bring us more in line with US Judge David O. Carter’s direction in the LA Alliance v. City/County of LA case,” said Councilmember Bob Blumenfield, one of the motion’s co-authors. 

On October 28, City Council debated the bill for hours before Council President Nury Martinez opted continue the vote on the controversial proposal on November 24. 

The ordinance was drafted by Los Angeles City Attorney Mike Feuer after it was requested recently by several members of City Council including Blumenfield. 

Among those who are opposed to the ordinance include Councilmember Mike Bonin who represents Pacific Palisades and much of the Westside. 

“It is reasonable to prohibit sleeping and lying on our sidewalks — IF genuine alternatives are truly available and accessible. But they are not. Without those housing alternatives, the ban on sleeping presented by the City Attorney would only serve to push encampments deeper into residential neighborhoods,” Bonin said. “That’s why I support commandeering underutilized hotels and motels for immediate use as homeless housing. This is an emergency situation and it requires emergency action, and using the hotels and motels will provide fast options for getting people off the streets and into housing.” 

A counter-proposal that did not pass by Bonin and Councilmember David Ryu called for what Bonin calls a “more aggressive approaches to providing housing, shelter and services”. 

At the center of the debate is a 2018 federal court ruling in the case Martin v. City of Boise which bars cities from punishing individuals from sleeping on public property unless they provide sufficient and accessible indoor housing.

“As long as there is no option of sleeping indoors, the government cannot criminalize indigent, homeless people for sleeping outdoors, on public property,” reads the ruling from the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, which includes both Idaho and California. 

In the decision, which ruled a City of Boise law penalizing homelessness unconstitutional, citing the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause of the Eighth Amendment, the court did give cities leeway to prohibit sleeping in public in certain situations. 

“Even where shelter is unavailable, an ordinance prohibiting sitting, lying, or sleeping outside at particular times or in particular locations might well be constitutionally permissible,” the decision reads.

According to Blumenfield, there is now a “plethora of beds locally” and therefore the city’s laws should be updated. 

“Since the ‘Boise decision’ from the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, the City of Los Angeles hasn’t been able to enforce laws against camping on sidewalks because shelters for the unhoused population were not available. Now that we are creating a plethora of beds locally, it’s time to bring our laws in line with the Boise decision and also draft regulations for sensitive areas like freeway underpasses and transit corridors,” Blumenfield said. “I’ve been speaking with community stakeholders about creating new ‘cabin communities’ and building Bridge Housing. I am often asked what will be done to make sure that unhoused people won’t set up camp around these sites. Part of this motion will ban living outside of the new interim housing sites. The goal is to house people, not have to enforce these laws.” 

Related Posts

Los Angeles Closes Playgrounds

December 2, 2020

December 2, 2020

Trails, beaches and other outdoor spaces remain open By Chad Winthrop The City of Los Angeles has closed playgrounds as...

Supervisor Sheila Kuehl Eats at Santa Monica Restaurant After Voting to Suspend Outdoor Dining

December 1, 2020

December 1, 2020

LA County Supervisor dines at Il Forno in Santa Monica last Tuesday By Sam Catanzaro LA County Supervisor Sheila Kuehl,...

Using Wildfire Modeling to Make Insurance More Affordable?

December 1, 2020

December 1, 2020

California Insurance Commissioner holding public meeting December 10 By Chad Winthrop The California Insurance Commissioner will hold a meeting to...

Former Chamber of Commerce President Roy Robbins Dies at Age 70: Palisades Today – November, 30, 2020

December 1, 2020

December 1, 2020

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes. * Former Chamber of Commerce President Roy Robbins Dies at Age 70...

Edify TV: Budget Cuts Leading to More Beach Pollution

December 1, 2020

December 1, 2020

Local budget cuts are leading to more trash and pollution on Westside beaches according to environmental experts. Learn more in...

Early 1900s Home Could be Replaced by Apartment Complex

November 30, 2020

November 30, 2020

Plans submitted to City of Santa Monica to convert 1546 9th Street in Santa Monica into more housing  By Toi...

Palisades Stakeholders Object to Possibility of Digital Bus Shelter Signs

November 30, 2020

November 30, 2020

Pacific Palisades Community Council and Palisades PRIDE send joint letter in opposition to proposal By Toi Creel Pacific Palisades stakeholders...

Local Steakhouse Named Best in LA

November 25, 2020

November 25, 2020

Acclaimed Brentwood steakhouse Baltaire wins 2020 honor By Kerry Slater An acclaimed local steakhouse has won the Best of Los...

Topanga House Goes up in Flames

November 25, 2020

November 25, 2020

Tuesday morning dryer fire put out by LA County firefighters By Sam Catanzaro A Topanga house went up in flames...

Four Private Palisades Schools Receive Waivers to Re-open: Palisades Today – November, 23, 2020

November 24, 2020

November 24, 2020

Local news and culture in under 5 minutes. * Four Private Palisades Schools Receive Waivers to Re-open * Homicides Reach...

Missing Man Last Seen in Pacific Palisades

November 24, 2020

November 24, 2020

LAPD says man Michael St. Jean last seen on September 27 in Pacific Palisades By Chad Winthrop Los Angeles police...

Passenger Parked in Pacific Palisades Dies After Traffic Collision

November 24, 2020

November 24, 2020

Three-car crash occurs over the weekend in Pacific Palisades By Sam Catanzaro A man died after the car he was...

Edify TV: 22-Story Office Building Planned for Westside

November 23, 2020

November 23, 2020

Learn about plans to bring a 22-story office building to the Westside in this video made possible by Santa Monica...

91-Year-Old Palisades Resident Sent to Hospital After Mugging at SM CVS

November 20, 2020

November 20, 2020

Woman robbed exiting CVS at Lincoln Boulevard and Santa Monica Boulevard over weekend By Sam Catanzaro A 91-year-old woman Pacific...